The dwarf tunnels are an endless maze! Who is stronger Eragon or Murtagh? Murtagh was the name of a character in the Star Wars Expanded Universe. Eragon joined strength with the elves and decided to test Murtagh in a battle of strength in magic. The moment Saphira touched down, Eragon vaulted off, then faltered, overcome by grief and anger. But why? He was the son of Morzan, the man who betrayed the Dragon Riders to Galbatorix and helped destroy them and the First (and Last) of The Forsworn (Wyrdfell in the Ancient Language) Selena, a young woman from the village Carvahall, fell in love with Morzan. Murtagh killed two of the men, saving Essie and her family. Faced with confronting the Kull on his own or entering the Varden, Murtagh reluctantly continued by Eragon's side. He was prepared to be imprisoned, tortured, as well as confined at all times, but did not give in. Why is my phone not turning on but charging? Thorn proved faster and stronger than Glaedr anticipated and the battle went on. He later apologized to Glaedr for his part in Oromis' death. Like Solo, Murtagh was a loner with an ambiguous past, who was pursued by powerful forces that eventually catch him. Dragons, elves and dwarves have been bewitching readers in recent years, and Christopher Paolini, author of the Inheritance trilogy, is no exception. She looked at him and Saphira, green eyes flashing, then continued watching for Ajihad. At one point, they were the ally of their half-sibling: during another, they were their enemy. Fortuitously, he was able to help rescue Eragon and Saphira from the Ra'zac, although Brom received a mortal wound in the process. Does arya love eragon? Angry at Eragon, Murtagh quickly bested him and . It makes no sense.. He was easy to hate given his arc, but I kind of sympathize with him. He was able to hide the stuff with nasuada though. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. Also, I really feel that if the other protagonists (e.g. Murtagh is a male human; who was at one point Eragon's ally, but was enslaved by Magic and forced to fight for the Broddring Empire. (Murtagh was pursued by the Broddring Empire, Jennsen was pursued by the House of Rahl.). Practically every decision was made for him. Beyond that, he no longer believed that life possessed inherent meaning not after seeing men torn apart by the Kull, a race of giant Urgals, and the ground a bed of thrashing limbs and the dirt so wet with blood it soaked through the soles of his boots. The Urgals converged on them, blocking Eragons view as he stared with rising horror and fear. During the battle Murtagh struck down the dwarf king Hrothgar. How can fate be this cruel, my old friend? He was clean-shaven, well tanned, fit, muscular, slightly taller (by about one to two inches) than his half-brother, Eragon, very strong and said to be strikingly handsome. When they began bringing him whatever he wanted from the library of Tronjheim, he quickly became fond of the scholarly environment. This article is about the character. Thorn is my dragon, and a thorn he shall be to all our enemies. Murtagh. I've always seen Murtagh as a parallel to Eragon. He then made Murtagh swear additional oaths that would ensure his complete obedience. When Eragon was traveling back to the Varden from Helgrind in Brisingr, he overheard a conversation between a group of Imperial soldiers. Murtagh is the way he is, because those chances for development were taken from him. 3 yr. ago. Murtagh is the way he is, because those chances for development were taken from him. Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings. He was killed attempting to escape with Murtagh from Ur'baen. Murtagh's mind, well-defended as it was, was augmented by the Eldunar given to him to control. Using the Way of Knowing, Eragon realized that Murtagh was the better swordsman and possessed too much determination for Eragon to defeat in a fair duel. and our For example, when Torkenbrand tried to capture him, Murtagh beheaded the slaver without hesitation, remorse, or emotion. Bear him and our companions back to Tronjheim on your shields and do not be ashamed to let your tears be seen, for this is a day of sorrow that all will remember. Jrmundur looked back at Tronjheim, his gaze distant. I disagree, hes not as developed as many characters but isnt exactly in a lot of the plot. Though he supported Galbatorix as the ruler of Alagasia, he harbored strong resentment against him and actually betrayed him in Inheritance. Selena, pregnant, worried for her children's fate and left Morzan. However, Murtagh repeatedly stated that he did not wish to join the Varden, as he did not share their desire to destroy the Broddring Empire as "it would only create chaos". However, during their last battle in Inheritance, Murtagh proved to possess superior combat ability to Eragon. It as we know did not ultimately occur in Star Wars, but is still a fun and ironic tidbit when comparing the two characters. Either way I would be very interested to read about their adventures together. They take different paths to end up in similar conditions. His true name changed slightly, but what he did with that new freedom is the important part. His reserves of magic were vast, due to the Eldunar he possessed, though he was still subjected to the rules of magic whenever he used his powers. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. In his hard life, he had few friends, except for Eragon, Saphira, Thorn, Tornac and Nasuada. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent. This level of cooperation and consideration for each other indicates that while Murtagh is stubborn and sometimes uncooperative, he and Thorn work very well together. He then raided the Varden camp, capturing Nasuada and bringing her back to Ur'baen, where Galbatorix tortured her. (Morzan threw Zar'roc at Murtagh when he was only three; Darken Rahl considered Jennsen an abomination of nature and a disappointing disgrace to the, They both fled their home while filled with grief after the death of a person close to them (, They were both pursued by the established government of their homeland, which tried to capture them. Then, a mercenary named Sarros leading a group of men, arrived the inn. He convinced a Dragon Rider to help him kill an elder rider to get revenge. When Murtagh became an unwilling servant of Galbatorix, he abhorred the atrocities he had to perform and disliked carrying them out. Eragon had been working on it for two years, and had spent a decent amount of time with The Elves and Oromis, but Murtagh was still able to 'outmagic' him, even with Saphira's combined strength. Eragon was forced to watch helplessly as the Urgals fell on the rear of Ajihads warriors; he could not work magic over such a distance. Before his uncle, Garrow, was slain by the Razac months earlier, the brutality that Eragon had witnessed between the humans, dwarves, and Urgals would have destroyed him. The others are already waiting for him by Tronjheims west gate. He used the ring of Aren to injure Thorn, infuriating Murtagh, who swore he would return. Bregan, theblind manwho saw lights and energies in Brisingr, described Murtagh's light, saying that the light shone through him as if his power came from another source. I hope we get more of him in the future. I am not evil! He had a good heart, and the world kinda screwed him over. Murtagh carried a yew bow and a white horn with silver fittings. He then reappeared with another rider named Morzan. The healers gave him various potions to drink. Galbatorix hid the true size of his army from the Varden with a powerful spell that took three days to pierce. When most, even his father, had given into, and even reveled in, the evil that had been thrust upon them. Eragon was bewildered at the news. Though he supported Galbatorix as the ruler of Alagasia, he harbored strong resentment against him and actually betrayed him in Inheritance. His experience in archery and wilderness survival allowed him to survive by hunting and foraging when on the run from the Broddring Empire. I loved to hate him, I think he's that kind of antagonist in a way. Join us here: https://discord.gg/jSUtbT6SHv, Press J to jump to the feed. Murtagh pierced Eragon in the hip with Zar'roc. Shruikan next appeared when the four warriors, Eragon, Arya, Saphira, and Elva confronted Galbatorix. Oddly, when Murtagh reappeared in Brisingr, he had black hair instead of brown. Although disgusted with him at first, she later warmed to him and started to reciprocate his feelings as he became her only companion. His primary weapon was a hand-and-a-half sword, which was later replaced by Zar'roc. He was also quite inventive as he placed spells in objects so he could use them quickly. Three days since he had killed Durza; three days since people began calling him Shadeslayer; three days since the remnants of the sorcerers consciousness had ravaged his mind and he had been saved by the mysterious Togira Ikonoka, the Cripple Who Is Whole. The world was cruel to Murtagh, his childhood was terrible, he was forced to live with his "captors" and I don't know if anyone here has heard of "Stockholm syndrome' but the fact that he doesn't suffer from this is very telling of his strength of will and character. Murtagh and Thorn returned to Ur'baen and from there went to Gil'ead, where they fought with Oromis and Glaedr. Also, Murtagh said something in the company of soldiers of the Broddring Empire that made them wonder if they were hunting down Murtagh himself. Murtagh was recognized to have fear in his eyes, but he and Thorn battled the elder pair fiercely nonetheless. On closer inspection, Murtagh's history and life closely parallels that of Jennsen Rahl of the Sword of Truth series. Or perhaps I'm mistaken? Im really interested in hearing what other people have to say. Orik pointed at a cluster of lanterns staked around a large tunnel opening a couple of miles away. Because of his unpleasant upbringing, a constant sense of danger and multiple attempts on his life, Murtagh became solitary, suspicious, as well as pragmatic. However, there is another character Murtagh is much more similar to, especially after Brisingr: The Witch-king of Angmar. Did Saphira and Firnen mate? Theyre not among the dead. Their respective fathers did not care much for them. Eragon nodded and headed toward the gate, keeping a hand on Saphira. The king, in a seemingly rare good mood, readily offered his "friendship" to the son of his deceased ally and Murtagh accepted it. And of course, this is only my opinion, so take it as you will. He was the main antagonist in Eldest. understood her meaning: Why her? Where will Ajihad come from? asked Eragon. Now it numbed him. Ajihad had been gone most of the three days, hunting down Urgals who had managed to escape into the dwarf tunnels that honeycombed the stone beneath the Beor Mountains. That makes the ending so much more meaningful. While the rumor most likely didn't have a real bearing on Paolini's plotting, it is still notable in how Murtagh and Eragon (The characters often compared to Han and Luke in the original book respectively) starting in Eldest are put into a strikingly similar situation where the former is captured and through mystical means forced into the service of their stories' respective ruling Empires with his then best friend (the main protagonist) having to face them as enemies. Murtagh also threatened to cut off Eragon's right hand during Brisingr (Vader succeeds in cutting off Luke's). No one can, except for Galbatorix. Murtagh. During Eldest, however, Murtagh becomes more similar to Anakin Skywalker (Darth Vader). He could barely assimilate the fact that Ajihad was dead and Murtagh missing. My mind is the only sanctuary that has not been stolen from me. Galbatorix then assumed full control over Murtagh, first speaking to Oromis and Glaedr through Murtagh, attempting to persuade the two ancient warriors to ally themselves with Galbatorix. [4] Murtagh continued to avoid the courts and its intrigues as much as was possible while living in King Galbatorix's castle at Ur'baen. He shied away from acts of excessive bloodshed and cruelty, such as the destruction of Cantos, as well as is willing to help others, such as Eragon, at certain times. He paused and turned to regard her. Before he left, Murtagh and Eragon said goodbye, acknowledging each other as brothers. He started writing his first book, "Eragon," at age 15, and by 19 had sold more than 2 million copies. He could immobilize fully grown dragons with a single word, heal even the most severe injuries in seconds and when coerced to use deadly force, he could unleash blasts of ruby energy strong enough to wipe out an entire group of spellcasters. Murtagh was targeted by the Twins and a group of Kull while exiting one of the tunnels and subsequently ensorcelled and taken back to Ur'baen. Eragon managed to outlast Murtagh in the brutal contest, but he and several of the elves fainted during the battle. Answer (1 of 3): Eragon and Murtagh have fought three times before but; * In the first fight, Eragon was weary after hours of battle, and Murtagh arrived ready to fight with the Eldunari on his side. While he had a difficult life, I don't think that necessarily excuses some of the things he's done. He is right, you must do all you can to avert a struggle for power. [1] In Inheritance, an intoxicated Murtagh comes to see Nasuada in the Hall of the Soothsayer. As the consistent player 2 growing up, his ranged attacks in the video game were way better than Brom's, so I've always had a soft spot for him. Later, however, he realized that he had made a mistake in doing so when Galbatorix commanded Murtagh to take a company of soldiers and destroy the village of Cantos, which was known to harbor rebels, as well as slaughter its population without even attempting to see if all of them were guilty or not. She had He bent and touched Ajihad on the shoulder. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser. The quiet that filled Farthen Dr suited him. Eragon knelt by him and lowered his face so his tears would not land on the leaders ruined chest. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads. Who is stronger Murtagh or Eragon? Together they killed the unknown rider and disappeared for a while. They were both the offspring of a powerful, cruel, dark lord, who was in the service of an even greater dark power (interestingly, their respective fathers. I hope that makes sense. Murtagh mac Erc ruled Ireland as High King from 512 to 534 A.D.[9]. That night, Murtagh fled Ur'baen with his faithful teacher, Tornac, who was an expert swordsman. After killing Hrothgar, Murtagh became a Kingkiller. magic inheritance-cycle Share I've done the best I could under the circumstances. But in my opinion he remained spiteful and shallow, Edit: but I do want to mention I think he acted admirably. Elation surged within him as he hurried to the tunnels mouth. He was the eldest of Selena's two children, the other of which is Eragon Shadeslayer; consequently being Eragon's half-brother and Roran Stronghammer's first cousin. At the age of three, Murtagh's back was laid open from shoulder to hip when Morzan threw his sword, Zar'roc, at the boy in a drunken rage. His wound twinged as Saphira lifted her azure wings, then drove them down and jumped forward, gaining speed and altitude each second. Can't find it asked anywhere, but does anyone have any idea why Murtagh tried to kill Eragon in their duel before Galbatorix? Saphira nosed one of the Urgals and said, This should not have happened. It was three days since the Varden and dwarves had fought the Urgals for possession of Tronjheim, the mile-high, conical city nestled in the center of Farthen Dr, but the battlefield was still strewn with carnage. What is the main cause of engine backfire? Eragon (the character) is a total Mary Sue/Gary Stu : he learns to fight with a sword in just a few weeks, his past is angsty, he's the first dragon rider for centuries, etc etc. Some of Murtagh's behavior, such as killing a person who attempts to capture him and bragging about his ride (Murtagh boasted about his horse, while Solo boasted about his ship), are similar to Han Solo's. With their bond to Galbatorix broken, Murtagh and Thorn went into self-imposed exile in the north of Alagaesiaso that they could find time to heal from what Galbatorix did to them. That's my take on this, and on most undeveloped characters as well. Later Murtagh played a crucial role in defending Dras-Leona by declaring himself to Eragon when he demanded they lower the city gates. Galbatorix must have received this information from . Eragon is soon swept into a dangerous tapestry of magic, glory, and power. They both developed very good foresting skills as a result. Sarros had found them, but apparently, something, or someone, had forced the group of the mercenaries to turn against Murtagh and to steal the stones. Eragon and Murtagh end up in the same place, and ultimately have the same goal. In the final book, Murtagh implied that Galbatorix only managed to penetrate his defenses by threatening Thorn, which echoed his previous statement to the Twins that they couldn't make him open his mind if they couldn't threaten Eragon's life. He had realized, with Saphiras help, that the only way to stay rational amid such pain was to do things. Galbatorix dealt Oromis a fatal blow using Murtagh's arm. In Brisingr, Arya's relationship with Eragon became very friendly and very close. Murtagh studied the possibility of changing his true name, which allowed him to disobey and even betray Galbatorix. They were conceived in a similar manner: their respective fathers seduced a young, seemingly innocent girl for their own benefit. But it is likely that they were forced to return due to Thorn's grave injury: Glaedr had bitten off several feet of his tail during the battle. Because of the aforementioned item, they both spent a lot of time traveling, moving through the wilderness and staying alert for any sign of danger. And if he was just trying to win, and knew Galbatorix wouldn't let him kill Eragon, why not go for a decisive, but non-lethal blow, like Eragon did. [6] The author went on to say that he thought it was without question going to be what happened, and cited scenes in the trailer that he thought helped affirm this. We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. What did the tree take from Eragon? Glaedr attempted to carry Oromis back to the elves, but was killed (only in the body) by Thorn. There are, however, several differences between Murtagh and Jennsen, including gender (Jennsen was female), the parent they shared with the main hero (in Murtagh's case it was his mother, in Jennsen's case it was her father) and the time periods in which they were allied with their half-sibling. But that's because I can relate to him. Eragon missed talking with Murtagh and looked forward to discussing all that had happened, once he returned. By clicking Accept All, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. It is implied than Murtagh was investigating something very important and dangerous. Betrayal and death [] During the aftermath of the battle, the Twins and Murtagh were captured by a troop of Urgals and were assumed dead. He was mistaken for a large curtain as he lay behind the Kings throne. Still, the dwarves were furious with her for destroying their most prized treasure. Im sorry, Eragon, but everyone important must stay here until Ajihads successor is chosen. Murtagh always exuded a calm, assured air, as well as his voice "is low and controlled, but curiously emotional". Arya, Roran, Nasuada, Eragon) had been put in the same position as him (i.e. But on the Burning Plains, Murtagh explicitly refused to do so, which shows that at the end of the day, he still valued his own life over everyone else's. He had trouble breathing past the lump in his throat, which was so hard it hurt. It reminded him too much of when he had returned to the farm to find his uncle Garrow dying. He was then dispatched to The Burning Plains, where an army of Imperial warriors were massed against those of Surda and the Varden, with orders to try to capture Eragon and Saphira. It surprised Eragon how much people's attitudes toward Murtagh had changed, considering that Murtagh's father was the Dragon Rider Morzan, who had betrayed the Riders to Galbatorix. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. . The Urgals must have taken them! He was a victim of fate, and had been since the day he was born. Eragon Shadeslayer, thinking about Murtagh. This caused Eragon much grief and started a conflict between them. He was a fiercely loyal companion and an accomplished swordsman. [2] When Morzan left to track down Saphira's egg, a pregnant Selena disappeared to secure a better life for her second child, Eragon. Because of his cruel lot in life and a past filled with agony, Murtagh delighted in striking back at the world that had shown him little kindness, the result of a suppressed desire for revenge all his life. It was at that moment I determined to escape him and Ur'baen forever. Murtagh. During Eldest, one of King Galbatorix's Dragon eggs hatched for Murtagh and he named the red Dragon Thorn. After Galbatorix's death, Murtagh appears to have recovered his moral compass, as in Ceunon, he regretted to being forced to kill, even to preserve his life, and proved to be very generous and valiant, risking his life to save a little girl he barely knows. Murtagh was able to temporarily disembody the Shade by shooting him between the eyes. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Like despite his tragic backstory, he's still great to hate. Does Murtagh betray Eragon? Eragon felt a strange thrill, as he always did when he saw the elf. His dragon Jarnunvsk was killed by Urgals some years later. After defeating him, Murtagh took Eragon's blade, Zar'roc, claiming that the sword was rightfully his.